Renting With Dogs: Breeds Landlords Often Avoid And Why

what breed of dogs to avoid when renting

When renting a home, it’s crucial to consider the breed of dog you own or plan to adopt, as some landlords and property managers have restrictions based on size, temperament, or insurance concerns. Breeds often avoided in rental situations include large or strong breeds like Pit Bulls, Rottweilers, and German Shepherds, which may be perceived as aggressive or high-risk. Additionally, breeds prone to excessive barking, such as Yorkshire Terriers or Pomeranians, might be discouraged due to noise complaints. Similarly, large breeds like Great Danes or Saint Bernards could be restricted due to their size and potential for accidental damage. Always check local laws and rental agreements, as breed-specific bans vary by region, and consider discussing your pet with the landlord to find a mutually agreeable solution.

shunrent

Large Breeds: Size restrictions in rentals often exclude big dogs like Great Danes

Renters with a penchant for large dog breeds often face a daunting challenge: size restrictions that bar their four-legged companions from apartments and rental homes. Great Danes, for instance, can weigh upwards of 150 pounds and stand over 30 inches tall, making them a prime example of a breed that frequently falls afoul of these rules. Landlords cite concerns about property damage, noise, and liability as reasons for these restrictions, but for dog lovers, this means navigating a minefield of limitations.

Consider the practical implications: a Great Dane’s sheer size can lead to accidental damage, such as knocking over furniture or scratching walls. Even well-trained dogs may struggle in tight living spaces, and their presence can increase wear and tear on flooring and doors. Landlords, wary of these risks, often opt for blanket bans on large breeds rather than assessing individual dogs. This one-size-fits-all approach leaves little room for negotiation, even if your dog is calm and well-behaved.

To mitigate these challenges, renters should proactively research pet policies before signing a lease. Some landlords may allow exceptions for service animals or emotional support dogs, but these require proper documentation, such as a letter from a licensed healthcare professional. Additionally, offering to pay a higher pet deposit or providing references from previous landlords can sometimes sway a property owner’s decision. However, these strategies are not foolproof, and rejection remains a real possibility.

For those unwilling to compromise on breed size, alternative housing options like pet-friendly condos or private rentals may offer more flexibility. These properties often have fewer restrictions and may even include amenities like dog parks or grooming stations. While they can be pricier, they provide a viable solution for renters determined to keep their large breed dog. Ultimately, the key is to balance your desire for a specific breed with the realities of the rental market, ensuring both you and your pet can thrive in your living space.

shunrent

Aggressive Breeds: Pit Bulls, Rottweilers, and others may face breed-specific bans

Renters with dogs often face breed restrictions, and aggressive breeds like Pit Bulls and Rottweilers top the list of banned dogs in rental properties. These restrictions stem from concerns over liability, safety, and insurance policies. Landlords and property managers frequently rely on breed-specific bans to mitigate risks, even though studies show that a dog’s behavior depends more on training and socialization than breed alone. If you own one of these dogs, prepare for challenges in finding pet-friendly housing.

Breed-specific bans often target Pit Bulls, Rottweilers, German Shepherds, Dobermans, and Mastiffs due to their perceived aggression and strength. Insurance companies may refuse coverage for properties with these breeds, leaving landlords financially vulnerable in case of incidents. For renters, this means limited options and higher costs, such as increased pet deposits or rent. To navigate this, research local laws, as some regions have outlawed breed-specific bans, offering legal protection for your dog.

If you own a breed prone to bans, proactive steps can improve your chances of securing a rental. First, obtain a Canine Good Citizen (CGC) certification to demonstrate your dog’s obedience and sociability. Second, provide references from previous landlords or trainers vouching for your dog’s behavior. Third, consider renter’s insurance with liability coverage to reassure landlords. Finally, be transparent about your dog’s breed and temperament during applications to build trust.

While breed-specific bans persist, advocacy efforts challenge their effectiveness. Organizations like the American Veterinary Medical Association argue that bans fail to address individual dog behavior and penalize responsible owners. Renters can contribute by sharing success stories of well-behaved dogs from restricted breeds and supporting legislation that promotes fair housing policies. By shifting the focus from breed to behavior, renters and advocates can work toward more inclusive pet policies.

Explore related products

War Dogs

$8.04 $10.34

War Dogs (Rental)

$18.69 $24.98

shunrent

High-Energy Dogs: Breeds like Border Collies may struggle in small rental spaces

High-energy dogs, such as Border Collies, Australian Shepherds, and Jack Russell Terriers, are bred for stamina and intense activity. These breeds excel in open fields or on farms, where they can run, jump, and work for hours. In a small rental space, however, their energy often becomes a liability. Without adequate outlets for physical and mental stimulation, they may resort to destructive behaviors like chewing furniture, barking excessively, or digging at carpets. For renters, this can lead to property damage, noise complaints, and strained relationships with landlords.

Consider the daily needs of a Border Collie, for instance. This breed requires at least 2 hours of vigorous exercise daily, including activities like fetch, agility training, or long walks. In a compact apartment, meeting this demand is nearly impossible. Even if you commit to multiple trips to the dog park, the confined indoor environment still lacks the space for spontaneous play or natural exploration. Over time, this mismatch between breed needs and living conditions can result in a frustrated, unhappy dog—and a stressed-out owner.

To mitigate these challenges, renters with high-energy dogs must adopt creative solutions. Interactive toys, such as puzzle feeders or treat-dispensing balls, can provide mental stimulation indoors. Short, intense training sessions—focusing on tricks or obedience commands—can also help burn energy. However, these strategies are not substitutes for physical exercise. If you’re renting and considering a high-energy breed, honestly assess your ability to commit to their needs. Otherwise, you risk creating an environment where neither you nor your dog can thrive.

A comparative perspective highlights why smaller, calmer breeds like French Bulldogs or Cavalier King Charles Spaniels are often better suited for rental living. These dogs require minimal exercise and are content with short walks and indoor play. While no breed is inherently “bad” for renting, high-energy dogs demand a level of accommodation that small spaces simply cannot provide. Before bringing a Border Collie or similar breed into an apartment, weigh the long-term consequences for both your living situation and the dog’s well-being.

Ultimately, the decision to adopt a high-energy dog in a rental space should not be taken lightly. If you’re set on a breed like a Border Collie, consider whether your lifestyle and environment align with their needs. For most renters, the practical takeaway is clear: opt for a breed whose energy levels match your living space. Otherwise, you may find yourself facing challenges that neither you nor your dog deserve.

shunrent

Heavy Shedders: Huskies and Saint Bernards can leave excessive fur, violating rental rules

Renters often face strict pet policies, and one common issue that can lead to violations is excessive shedding. Among the culprits, Huskies and Saint Bernards stand out as breeds that can turn your cozy apartment into a fur-covered nightmare. These dogs are beloved for their striking appearances and loyal personalities, but their heavy shedding can quickly become a landlord’s—and your—worst enemy. If you’re considering either breed while renting, it’s crucial to weigh the challenges their fur presents against your living situation.

Huskies, with their thick double coats, shed heavily twice a year during seasonal changes, a process known as "blowing coat." During this time, they can lose enough fur to knit a sweater. Even outside these periods, they shed moderately year-round. Saint Bernards, on the other hand, have a dense, water-resistant coat that sheds consistently, leaving tufts of fur on furniture, floors, and clothing. Both breeds require frequent grooming, but even with regular brushing, the sheer volume of fur can be overwhelming in a rental space. Landlords often enforce "no excessive shedding" clauses to protect carpets, upholstery, and air quality, making these breeds risky choices.

To mitigate shedding-related issues, consider investing in high-quality grooming tools like an undercoat rake or deshedding brush. Brushing your dog 2–3 times a week can reduce loose fur, but it’s not a foolproof solution. Additionally, using a pet vacuum and lint rollers regularly can help maintain cleanliness. However, these efforts may not satisfy strict rental agreements, especially if neighbors share ventilation systems or common areas. For renters, the cost of professional cleaning or potential deductions from security deposits can outweigh the benefits of owning a heavy-shedding breed.

Comparing Huskies and Saint Bernards, Huskies may be slightly more manageable due to their smaller size, but their shedding intensity is comparable. Saint Bernards, being larger, produce more fur overall, which can exacerbate the problem in smaller living spaces. If you’re set on one of these breeds, discuss pet policies with your landlord upfront and propose a cleaning plan. Some landlords may be open to negotiations, but many will prioritize property maintenance over exceptions. Ultimately, while Huskies and Saint Bernards are wonderful dogs, their shedding habits make them high-risk choices for renters.

For those unwilling to compromise, consider low-shedding alternatives like poodles, Schnauzers, or Bichon Frises. These breeds are better suited to rental living and can provide companionship without the fur-filled fallout. If your heart is set on a Husky or Saint Bernard, explore pet-friendly housing options or prepare for the challenges ahead. Balancing your love for these breeds with rental realities requires careful planning, but it’s not impossible—just be prepared to put in the work.

shunrent

Noisy Breeds: Barkers like Chihuahuas or Beagles might disturb neighbors in close quarters

Living in close quarters with neighbors means every sound carries, and a barking dog can quickly become a source of tension. Breeds like Chihuahuas and Beagles, while beloved for their personalities, are notorious for their vocal tendencies. Chihuahuas, despite their small size, have a big bark and often alert their owners to every passing leaf or shadow. Beagles, bred as hunting dogs, have a loud, baying bark that can carry far and persist for long periods. If you’re renting, these breeds may not be the best fit unless you’re prepared to invest significant time in training and soundproofing.

Consider the environment before choosing a breed. Apartments or townhouses with thin walls amplify noise, making even moderate barking disruptive. If you’re set on a noisy breed, start training early. Teach your dog the "quiet" command and reward them for silence. Use positive reinforcement, not punishment, to avoid increasing anxiety-driven barking. For Chihuahuas, address their territorial instincts by socializing them early and providing a designated safe space. For Beagles, ensure they get plenty of exercise to reduce boredom-induced barking.

Another practical tip is to invest in noise-reducing tools. White noise machines or calming music can mask barking sounds for neighbors. If your dog barks when you’re away, consider a doggy daycare or a pet sitter to keep them company. For persistent barkers, consult a professional trainer or animal behaviorist to identify and address the root cause. Remember, while you may find your dog’s barking endearing, your neighbors likely do not.

Finally, if you’re renting and unsure about a breed’s suitability, have an honest conversation with your landlord or property manager. Some may be more lenient if you demonstrate a plan to manage noise. Alternatively, consider breeds known for their quiet nature, like Bulldogs or Basset Hounds, which are less likely to disturb neighbors. Choosing the right dog for your living situation isn’t just about your preferences—it’s about being a considerate neighbor.

Frequently asked questions

Landlords often restrict breeds like Pit Bulls, Rottweilers, German Shepherds, Doberman Pinschers, and Akitas due to perceived aggression or liability concerns.

Landlords may avoid certain breeds due to insurance restrictions, liability fears, or stereotypes about aggression, even if the individual dog is well-behaved.

Not always. While small breeds like Chihuahuas or Yorkshire Terriers are often permitted, some landlords still enforce breed or weight restrictions regardless of size.

You can try negotiating with the landlord, providing proof of training, or offering to pay a higher pet deposit, but breed restrictions are often non-negotiable.

Not necessarily. Some landlords restrict dogs based on physical appearance or traits associated with certain breeds, even if the dog is a mix. Always check the specific policy.

Written by
Reviewed by
Share this post
Print
Did this article help you?

Leave a comment